Bread Pitt
All bakes

BAKE004 · September 3–September 4, 2026

Light Whole Wheat Sandwich Loaf

A strong rise, a soft and even crumb, and a reminder that the dough gets the final vote.

Recipe
Light Whole Wheat Sourdough Sandwich Loaf
Starter
Bread Pitt 2.0
Rating
9/10 thumbs up
Bake004 cooling after an excellent rise and a rich golden bake.
Bake004 cooling after an excellent rise and a rich golden bake.

The fourth bake on Bread Pitt was the first full run of the published Light Whole Wheat Sourdough Sandwich Loaf recipe.

Mixing and Building Strength

Bread Pitt was in a good mood that morning. The starter was active, bubbly, and ready to go, so the dough came together without any surprises.

Bread Pitt active, bubbly, and ready for Bake004.
Bread Pitt active, bubbly, and ready for Bake004.

After a short autolyse, the salt and olive oil went in, followed by about eight minutes of mixing. The dough came together into a smooth ball and headed into bulk fermentation.

Bread Pitt and water in Dough Cloony at the start of the mix.
Bread Pitt and water in Dough Cloony at the start of the mix.
The shaggy dough before its short autolyse.
The shaggy dough before its short autolyse.
The dough developing strength six minutes into mixing.
The dough developing strength six minutes into mixing.
A smooth, cohesive dough at the end of mixing.
A smooth, cohesive dough at the end of mixing.

The first fold showed a little tearing, which isn't unusual with a dough that still has some whole wheat in it.

The dough before the first fold.
The dough before the first fold.
The dough after the first fold, with a little surface tearing still visible.
The dough after the first fold, with a little surface tearing still visible.

By the second fold the tearing had disappeared.

The dough relaxing before the second fold.
The dough relaxing before the second fold.
A smoother, stronger dough after the second fold.
A smoother, stronger dough after the second fold.

By the third fold the dough had developed the strength I was looking for. From there it was just a matter of waiting.

The dough before the third and final fold.
The dough before the third and final fold.
The dough holding its shape after the third fold.
The dough holding its shape after the third fold.

Bulk Fermentation

Bulk fermentation took a little over seven hours. Using the new Cambro container made it easier to keep an eye on the dough, although I learned that a smaller, straighter-sided container would make judging the rise even easier in future bakes. The dough continued to expand steadily throughout the afternoon until it looked ready for shaping.

The start of bulk fermentation in the new Cambro container.
The start of bulk fermentation in the new Cambro container.
The dough beginning to expand during bulk fermentation.
The dough beginning to expand during bulk fermentation.
Steady fermentation progress through the afternoon.
Steady fermentation progress through the afternoon.
The dough becoming fuller and more aerated late in bulk.
The dough becoming fuller and more aerated late in bulk.
Bulk fermentation complete after a little over seven hours.
Bulk fermentation complete after a little over seven hours.

The Overnight Proof

After shaping, the loaf wasn't going to finish proofing before bedtime. Rather than rushing it or baking late, I slid the pan into the refrigerator for an overnight proof. That's one of the nice things about sourdough—it can usually adapt to your schedule if you're willing to be patient.

The shaped loaf at the start of its final proof.
The shaped loaf at the start of its final proof.
The loaf just before its overnight rest in the refrigerator.
The loaf just before its overnight rest in the refrigerator.
The fully proofed loaf ready for the oven the next morning.
The fully proofed loaf ready for the oven the next morning.

The next morning, after about two hours back at room temperature, the loaf looked ready. Into the oven it went.

The Results

It rewarded the patience with one of my better sandwich loaves so far. The oven spring was excellent, the crust baked to a rich golden brown, and the crumb was exactly what I wanted from a daily sandwich bread: soft, even, and sturdy enough to hold together while still feeling light.

Bake004 cooling after an excellent rise and a rich golden bake.
Bake004 cooling after an excellent rise and a rich golden bake.

A few larger holes appeared near the top of the loaf, but overall the crumb was uniform and sliced beautifully.

The soft, even crumb of the finished sandwich loaf.
The soft, even crumb of the finished sandwich loaf.

This bake also reinforced something I've been learning over the past few months. Times printed in recipes are useful starting points, but the dough always gets the final vote. Watching how it develops, rather than chasing the clock, consistently produces better bread.

Bread Pitt Rating

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

9/10 thumbs up

The loaf turned out exactly the way I hoped. The only thing keeping it from a perfect score is that I'd like to refine the shaping a little more to eliminate the occasional larger air pocket near the top. Otherwise, this is a recipe I'll happily bake again.